A new paper: Two problematic sclerobiont species that survived the Ordovician-Silurian extinction event

It was again my privilege to join my Estonian colleagues on a paper (published today in Palaeoworld) describing sclerobionts (hard-substrate dwelling organisms) from the Lower Paleozoic. This time we record the earliest species of the problematic genus Allonema, finding them in the Upper Ordovician, a range extension downward from the Lower Silurian. Of particular interest is the observation that these two species passed through the end-Ordovician mass extinction, appearing as common encrusters in the Lower Silurian. This survival is no mean feat considering this extinction eliminated up to 70% of marine species (Zhang et al., 2025). The image above is one of the species, Allonema moniliforme (Whiteaves, 1891), from the lower Katian of northern Estonia (GIT 770-1-6), Figure 8A of the paper. The scale bar is 0.5 mm. (These are very small!)

Abstract.–Two species of the encrusting calcitic sclerobiont Allonema have been identified for the first time in the Ordovician. Allonema moniliforme and A. botellus were originally known only from the Silurian but are here recorded from the Katian (Upper Ordovician) of Estonia. A. moniliforme reappears in the Rhuddanian–Aeronian of Estonia, and A. botellus emerges again in the Sheinwoodian of Gotland. Both species are unknown in the Hirnantian (latest Ordovician), and both survived the end-Ordovician extinction. Both species lived in similar, calm, muddy environments during their Ordovician and Silurian appearances. During the Silurian, Allonema was a much more common and widespread encruster than in the Ordovician, occurring on a broad range of biogenic hard substrates. This difference may reflect ecological and evolutionary shifts following the Late Ordovician mass extinction, which reorganized marine ecosystems and opened new niches. A. botellus maintained a stable morphology across the Ordovician–Silurian boundary, A. moniliforme underwent a narrowing of its morphological variability, possibly reflecting evolutionary canalization or shifts in ecological pressures over time.

Note that we do not explain exactly what Allonema was. It is a beautiful little series of connected calcitic chambers with numerous pores. They are always found encrusting hard substrates, usually shells. Paul Taylor and I (Wilson and Taylor, 2014) referred to them as “pseudobryozoans” because they were commonly confused with real bryozoans. We’re sure they were not foraminiferans, either. They for now are classified as incertae sedis (meaning “uncertain placement”).

This gives me an excuse to include one of Paul Taylor’s wonderful scanning electron microscope images below.

Allonema from the Silurian of Gotland, Sweden. From Figure 1D of Wilson and Taylor (2014); Scale bar is 500 µm.

A fun mystery, Allonema is, and now we know just a bit more about it.

References:

Vinn, O., Wilson, M.A., Toom, U., Tinn, O. and Lang, L., 2026. Two species of Allonema: Problematic sclerobionts that survived the end-Ordovician extinction in Baltica. Palaeoworld, p.201104.

Wilson, M.A. and Taylor, P.D., 2014. The morphology and affinities of Allonema and Ascodictyon, two abundant Palaeozoic encrusters commonly misattributed to the ctenostome bryozoans. Studi Trentini di Scienze Naturali, 94, p. 259-266.

Zhang, Z., Yang, C., Sahy, D., Zhan, R.B., Wu, R.C., Li, Y., Deng, Y., Huang, B., Condon, D.J., Rong, J. and Li, X.H., 2025. Tempo of the Late Ordovician mass extinction controlled by the rate of climate change. Science Advances, 11(22), p.eadv6788.

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , | Leave a comment

Voices in the Trees: Update on the Alaska Youth Stewards and The College of Wooster Tree-Ring Lab Collaboration at Five Years

Participants: Greg Wiles, Nick Wiesenberg, Ben Gaglioti, Daniel Mann, Gabrielle Sjoberg, Eloise Peabbles, Eric Benedict, Julian Narvaez, Bob Girt, Arianna Lapke, Lilly Hinkley, Amanda Flory, Michail Protopapadakis, Wenshuo Zhao, Tyrell Cooper,  Lynnsey Delio, Isabel Held, Dexter Pakula, Landon Vaughan, Lev Sugerman-Brozan, and AYS students.

General: For the past five years faculty, staff, and students from The College of Wooster Tree Ring Lab, University of Alaska, Fairbanks and the Alaska Youth Stewards (AYS) from Kake, Hoonah, Angoon and Klawock in Southeast Alaska (SEAK) have been collaborating to understand environmental change through the collection of tree-ring data. Together, we sampled and processed eight tree-ring chronologies from a previously under-sampled region of SEAK. These data are records of past climate with direct linkages to cultural and land-use histories. The collection includes the first two western redcedar (Thuja plicata) series for Alaska, one from Kake based on the farthest known north stand of redcedar in its natural range and the other from Klawock. The remaining chronologies include three Alaska yellow cedar (Callitropsis nootkatensis) series from Kake, Hoonah and Klawock, a Sitka spruce (Picea sitchensis) series from Angoon, and two mountain hemlock (Tsuga mertensiana) series from Hoonah and Angoon.

Background: The collaboration started remotely in the summer of 2021 – the summer of 2022 was a visit to Kake, then Hoonah (2023), Klawock (2024) and then in 2025 Angoon. Throughout the years, all the AYS (Alaska Youth Stewards) groups continued coring trees and sending samples to The Wooster Tree Ring lab and meeting online.

Map showing the location of the eight ring-width sites from Southeast Alaska. Table 1 shows the attributes of each of these chronologies. Note the natural north south transect on which these collections fall.

Table 1. List of the 8 tree-ring sites generated through this collaboration.

KAKE

The Hamilton Grove chronology from Kake western redcedar. This redcedar chronology is the first for Alaska and was sampled at the northernmost redcedar site. Other sites further north have been reported, but are not confirmed (pers. comm. B.Buma). The climate signal here is a strong positive relationship with winter temperatures.

Initial analyses of the red cedar site on a beautiful day on the shores outside of Kake.

Berry picking was high on the list after the work was done.

HOONAH

The Hoonah Ear Mountain hemlock site. This site strongly reflects some of the volcanically-forced marker years from the region (late 1690s, 1809, 1883) along with the enigmatic year of 1973, which is a narrow marker year with an uncertain climatic reason.

 Alaska yellow cedar near Hoonah stripped between 2001 and 2006 CE (Common Era). The year of stripping was determined by coring within and outside of the scar and then taking the difference between the total rings in each core. The stripping is sustainable and not detected as a decline in growth in the ring-width series.

Pickling bull kelp in Hoonah.

KLAWOCK

The Klawock-Wooster group in the forest.

Yellow cedar ring-width series from Klawock – three of the major Northern Hemisphere cooling volcanic eruptions are evident in the record. Comparisons with monthly minimum temperatures from Ketchikan show that March-September correlates most strongly (r = 0.39, p < 0.006, N = 67).

Posing in the yard where yellow and red cedar logs are archived for the artists that will choose these giants for carving canoes and totems.

The group working on yellow cedar cores.

ANGOON

S’eiltin Jamiann Hasselquist (far right) directed the group for a few days of cemetery work in Angoon.

The Hood Bay Mountain, mountain hemlock ring-width chronology. This series is a record of June-August temperatures and shows the volcanic cooling associated with volcanic eruptions at 1698 and 1809. Note also the drop-off after the mid-1970s.

The group peels back the moss and vines to reveal another Tlingit grave.

Acknowledgements: This work was supported by the National Science Foundation under grants P2C2-2002561and P2C2-2002454, and through the Keck Geology Consortium NSF grant 2050697. We also thank The College of Wooster Danner Fund.

Wooster participants on the first trip to Kake.

References (the tree-ring data are available using the links below): 

Wiles, G.; Wiesenberg, N., 2026. Turn Point Update – PISI – ITRDB AK213, https://www.ncei.noaa.gov/access/paleo-search/study/44480https://doi.org/10.25921/tc7z-cf17

Wiles, G.; Wiesenberg, N.; Zhao, W.; Hinkley, L., 2026. Hamilton Grove – THPL – ITRDB AK216, https://www.ncei.noaa.gov/access/paleo-search/study/44483, https://doi.org/10.25921/rsgt-1519

Wiles, G.; Wiesenberg, N.; Flory, A.; Protopapadakis, M., 2026. Klawock Redcedar Comp – THPL – ITRDB AK217, https://www.ncei.noaa.gov/access/paleo-search/study/44484, https://doi.org/10.25921/ekbp-3m14

Wiles, G.; Wiesenberg, N.; Flory, A.; Protopapadakis, M., 2026. Klawock Yellow Cedar Comp – CHNO – ITRDB AK218, https://www.ncei.noaa.gov/access/paleo-search/study/44485, https://doi.org/10.25921/4k9k-1c63

Wiles, G.; Wiesenberg, N.; Cooper, T.F.; Gaglioti, B.V.; Hinkley, L., 2026. Hoonah Yellow Cedar – CHNO – ITRDB AK219, https://www.ncei.noaa.gov/access/paleo-search/study/44486, https://doi.org/10.25921/4bhp-1b59

Wiles, G.; Wiesenberg, N.; Cooper, T.F.; Gaglioti, B.V.; Hinkley, L., 2026. Hoonah Ear Mountain – TSME – ITRDB AK222, https://www.ncei.noaa.gov/access/paleo-search/study/44489, https://doi.org/10.25921/9pwx-mc46

Wiles, G.; Wiesenberg, N., 2026. Hood Bay Mountain – TSME – ITRDB AK223, https://www.ncei.noaa.gov/access/paleo-search/study/44490, https://doi.org/10.25921/mr27-g619

 

 

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , , , , , , | 1 Comment

Dr. Nicolás Young – Our 44th Annual Osgood Speaker

It was a honor to welcome Dr. Nicolás Young (’05) back to the College to be our 44th Osgood Speaker. Dr. Young hails from the Lamont-Doherty Earth Observatory’s Cosmo Lab, where he is a Associate Research Scientist. Nicolás is a leader in developing the analytical side of cosmogenic surface exposure dating and is a gifted and creative field geologist.

His Osgood talk “Disappearance of North Atlantic ice sheets over the last 2.6 million years”  focused on his work with colleagues aimed at trying to figure out what ice sheets may have looked like during past warm intervals in Earth’s recent history, which is particularly important considering Earth’s current climate trajectory. This work is extremely challenging because evidence of small ice sheets has largely been destroyed by repeated episodes of subsequent ice advance. His team has been combining new sampling approaches in the field with evolving geochemical techniques to better constrain what ice sheets may have looked like during the past warm times. He outlined methods of sampling bedrock along ice sheet margins (Barnes Ice Cap) that has become ice free in the last few years, and drilling through existing ice to sample bedrock currently resting beneath extant ice sheets (Greenland). He deftly described how geochemical measurements from these unique samples help determine how often in the recent geologic past the Laurentide and Greenland ice sheets completely disappeared.  This work focused on recent results of a major project Greendrill as well as his ongoing projects on Baffin Island’s Barnes Ice Cap.

News to many in the audience is that the Laurentide Ice Sheet still exists as the remanent Barnes Ice Cap on Baffin Island in the Canadian Arctic. It was the Barnes Ice Cap and the fascinating story of its recent (the last few millennia) history that blew many of us away. Nicolás presented these recent results to our Geoclub. Note the trimline around the extent of the ice cap pictured above in this Sentinel image.

Nicolás speaking to Geoclub on his recent discoveries at the Barnes Ice Cap.

I can’t give the story away as the article is in review (I will post again when it comes out). The gray trimline area seen in the figure above marks a “recent” advance to this 1960 CE position, after which retreat has dominated. Nicolás described the trimline as a knife-edge and that only through careful dating using cosmogenic isotopes could one determine when this “recent” advance of ice began. The significance of this recent advance of the remanent of the Laurentide Icesheet is remarkable and transforms our thinking of Earth’s recent climate history.

We greatly thank the Osgood family for endowing the funds to bring innovative science to our Wooster community each year.

 

 

 

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

Dating a Cabin from Pittsburgh

Dr. Mark Abbott and his graduate students Cole and Adeel visited the Wooster Tree Ring Lab with portions of white oak beams from a historic cabin in Pittsburgh. The mission was to tree ring date the outer ring of the samples to determine which calendar year the timber was cut for the structure. Here the Pitt team in the sample prep. lab with the two samples where they polished them for analysis.

Nick Wiesenberg oversaw the dating, which started with a tour in the west wing of the Wooster Tree Ring Lab.

Adeel measured one of the samples – understandably he is amazed with the anatomy of the white oak rings.

Cole measured the other sample measuring ring widths from the screen using CooRecorder. The Pitt group are exports in lake core analysis and both Adeel and Cole are analyzing lake varves, they are also thinking about using this measuring setup for varve analyses (see below).

Nick takes the controls and analyzes the measurement data against our tree-ring database and reveals the date of cutting for the cabin.

The crossdating with our master series shows that the outer ring of the samples were both 1834, at least for the two samples both were cut in the same year after the 1834 growing season so the cabin was likely built shortly after this. The 1698/99 rings are strong markers.

The varves that the Pitt team are analyzing are shown above – they may be annual like tree-rings and their research will extract paleoenvironmental data from these. This core was taken by the group a few weeks before their visit to Wooster in Northern Minnesota where it was tens of degrees below zero. See below.

The coring operation in Minnesota – ~12 inches of ice and 60 feet of water and then a few tens of meters of mud is the sequence through this ice hole.

Posted in Uncategorized | 1 Comment

A new paper describing the feeding apparatus of Silurian cornulitids from China: More evidence supporting placement of this group in the lophophorates

It was my privilege to join an Estonian-Polish-Chinese-American team interpreting partial soft-tissue preservation of the feeding devices of Silurian cornulitids, which are extinct Paleozoic organisms that constructed small conical, ribbed tubes. Cornulitids are very common sclerobionts (hard-substrate dwellers) in the Upper Ordovician Cincinnatian Group of Indiana, Kentucky and Ohio, so these are familiar fossils to Wooster geologists. Now we know a little bit more about their paleobiology. Our new paper can be downloaded here.

The top image is from Figure 3A of Vinn et al. (2026). It is Cornulites cf. cellulosus (HWR007a) showing a fully protracted likely lophophore (filter-feeding device). Scale bar is 5 mm.

Abstract.–Circular structures observed at the apertures of several Cornulites specimens from the earliest Silurian of China are interpreted as possible fossilized remains of a lophophore with a simple, ring-like morphology. These structures may represent partial preservation of the feeding apparatus, with the absence of tentacle preservation likely resulting from taphonomic processes. The preserved rim surrounding the circular structure likely reflects the thickness of the lophophore and its tentacles, while a neck-like extension visible in one specimen is interpreted as the basal region of the lophophore. Specimens displaying a partially extended lophophore suggest that Cornulites individuals may have been capable of retracting their lophophore entirely into the shell, between feeding episodes, although complete retraction remains speculative. These partial soft-­tissue remains support the classification of cornulitids as lophophorates. However, the available evidence remains insufficient to definitively resolve whether cornulitids are more closely related to bryozoans or phoronids. As the only shelled benthic fossils in the Huangshi deposits, cornulitids seemed to have been opportunistic organisms which were able to colonize and thrive in oxygen-deficient palaeoenvironments following the Late Ordovician mass extinction.

From Figure 4 of Vinn et al. (2026). Cornulites sp. (specimen HWR072a-1) interpreted as showing a partially retracted lophophore. Scale bar is 5 mm.

From Figure 5 of Vinn et al. (2026). Schematic line drawing of Cornulites cf. cellulosus (HWR007a) showing a fully protracted lophophore. Scale bar 5 mm.

Cornulitids are old friends to those Wooster geologists who studied Ordovician fossils in paleo courses. This is the genus Cornulites Schlotheim 1820, specifically Cornulites flexuosus (Hall 1847). It was found in the Whitewater Formation (Late Ordovician, Katian) during a College of Wooster field trip to southeastern Indiana (C/W-148; N 39.78722°, W 84.90166°).

I thank my international co-authors for inviting me to join this team.

Reference:

Vinn, O., Zong, R., Wilson, M.A., Liu, Y. and Zatoń, M. 2026. Partially preserved cornulitid feeding apparatuses from the lowest Silurian of South China support the lophophorate affinities of this enigmatic group. Lethaia https://doi.org/10.18261/let.59.3

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , | Leave a comment

Paleoecology (2025) and New Displays in Scovel Hall

Dr. Lyon’s class along with her TAs and in collaboration with the Wooster Art Museum’s director Dr. Marianne Wardle, significantly upgraded many of the fossil and mineral displays in Scovel Hall this past fall.

The classes hard work was revealed in an “opening” on the last day of Geoclub with students presenting their work to the Wooster Earth Scientists.

 

One of the formerly empty cases in the North entrance of Scovel Hall is now populated with new displays that are Ohio-centric.

Each of the geologic time periods is represented, and in this case, fossils from Ohio are keyed to each period are explained.

A detail of one of the cases and Ohio’s fossils.

Another new addition to Scovel Hall is a case on the first floor with examples of various modes of preservation and remarkable aesthetics in the setup with cards that offer explanations for each specimen.

Modes of preservation was a topic in much of the interpretive materials in the first floor case.

A detail from one of the shelves of the first – floor case.

Departmental technician, Nick Wiesenberg, painted over the not-so-nice pink color that was pervasive in our building, making this almost-three-story-wall shades of blue to provide an oceanic backdrop. Its great to see these displays each day and to see an increase in student, faculty, staff and visitors reading and interacting with the materials. Thank you Dr. Lyon, students and TAs from Paleoecology as well as the Wooster Art Museum and Nick for his support of this project.

Posted in Uncategorized | 3 Comments

A New Paper on Deciduous Conifers at Secrest Arboretum

Imagine a world with larch trees in the uplands and dawn redwoods in the flats, and bald cypress trees in the wetlands. This existed in the Eocene (~40 million years ago) when the world was warmer, the treeline was at higher latitudes and altitudes, and carbon dioxide in the atmosphere was more than two times Earth’s preindustrial levels. In fact, in the high Arctic where no trees can survive today, deciduous conifers were as lush in terms of carbon sequestration and bioproductivity as today’s rain forests.  Now, imagine a world that is sliding back into the greenhouse after millions of years of relative icehouse conditions.

How can we better understand the role of deciduous conifers in the biosphere and their utility in a warmer world. One “natural” experiment is to use dendroclimatology to infer the response of deciduous conifers to a warmer and wetter world. Secrest Arboretum in Wooster, Ohio has two species of larch trees (Siberian and European) as well as bald cypress and dawn redwood trees. These species are all exotic to Ohio and have been growing in the arboretum in some cases for over 100 years. How do they grow in their new homes? This is the subject of a new paper from the Wooster Tree Ring Lab published in Plants People and Planet.Dawn Redwoods from the Arboretum

The Weather station active in the Arboretum since the late 1800s provided the monthly climate records.

Here is the upshot of the work: Rising temperatures and wetter conditions in the Midcontinent of North America are influencing climate responses in trees. Dendroclimatological analyses of the four exotic deciduous conifer species from Secrest Arboretum, Northeast Ohio help identify past, present, and future climate-tree interactions. Analyses suggest that two larch species have changed their response to climate, whereas dawn redwoods and bald cypress trees are well suited for the present and future climate. This study elucidates tree responses to climate gleaned from a largely untapped source of tree growth in arboreta that can be more broadly applied at other sites as well as facilitate forest management decisions.

This effort included professors, staff and students at The College of Wooster as well as our collaborator and geo-ecologist Dr. Ben Gaglioti from the University of Alaska – Fairbanks. We thank Jason Veil (the curator of Ohio State University’s Secrest Arboretum) and its staff and volunteers for managing this amazing facility and for allowing us to sample the trees. We also acknowledge support of the National Science Foundation, Division of Earth Sciences, Grant/Award Numbers: EAR 2039939, GP-2023154.

Posted in Uncategorized | 1 Comment

A Blast from the Past: Paleoecology 2025 Visits Cleveland Museum of Natural History

by Claire Elsie and Allie Toombs, with contributions from other Paleoecology students.

On Saturday, November 8th, Dr. Lyon’s paleoecology class visited the Cleveland Museum of Natural History for inspiration for our own museum project. We explored the exhibits and analyzed their strengths and weaknesses. This allowed us to gain valuable insight into museum design, along with increasing our knowledge of topics we learned in class.

Figure 1.  The 2025 Fall Paleoecology class at the Cleveland Museum of Natural History with Ohio’s famous fossil fish, Dunk (Dunkleosteus)!

Dunk has become a mascot for the class, with its charismatic features and deep Ohio significance.

Figure 2. An exhibit describing ancient rocks and fossils of Ohio, with a geologic map.

This exhibit provided details on local paleogeography, and the map specifically allowed viewers to connect with places they are familiar with. The display uses vibrant color and intentionally well-placed labeling which draws people in. This is a great inspiration for our own wall art and display design!

Figure 3. An immersive animated exhibit that brings the prehistoric oceans to life, showcasing ancient predator and prey relationships. It cycles through numerous facts about our favorite fossil fish, Dunkleosteus!

Figure 4. Banded iron formation (BIF) specimen, exemplifying what we learned in class!

Banded iron formations are formed of alternating layers of chert and hematite or magnetite and reflect the presence or absence of free oxygen. As oxygen becomes more abundant in the atmosphere, free iron in the water is oxidized, and BIFs form less.

Figure 5. A display featuring a dinosaur fossil and trace fossil footprints, along with paleoart in the background.

This display does a great job of integrating different display types and sizes, and the paleoart helps bring it to life. This is a wonderful example of a well-designed exhibit and great inspiration for our Scovel display.

Figure 6. Fossil of the Parasaurolophus, which the class learned about in a case study presented by class TA, Taylor Grant.

Parasaurolophus were herbivorous bipedal dinosaurs that lived in the swamps and dense forests of the last Cretaceous. Fossils have been found in Alberta, Canada, Utah, and Mexico. The crest, as seen in the fossil, is actually an elongated nasal cavity! This was a great learning experience and allowed us to apply topics and ideas learned in class.

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , | 2 Comments

A Tradition Continues: Richmond, Indiana – Paleoecology, Fall 2025

Blog post written by students enrolled in the course, including Madeline Eaton and Lynnsey Delio.

On August 30th, Dr. Lyon’s Paleoecology class took a trip down to Richmond, Indiana to collect fossils for their lab project. The class found many different types of fossils from the Upper Ordovician Whitewater Formation that are 458.2 to 443.1 million years old! During the Ordovician Period, Ohio was covered by shallow seas that were home to many creatures such as brachiopods, horn corals, bryozoans, bivalves, and more. The constant accumulation of sediment during this time made conditions perfect for rapid burial and fossilization of organisms.

Figure 1. The Paleoecology class collecting fossils from the Whitewater Formation. Millions of years ago shallow seas dominated this area, creating the perfect habitat for a host of diverse organisms.

Figure 2. A horn coral from the Ordovician time period, collected from the Whitewater Formation with a student’s hand for scale.

Figure 3. Students searching for fossil specimens.

Figure 4. A bountiful harvest of fossilized taxa from the Whitewater Formation in Richmond, IN. This picture includes different types of corals, bryozoans, and brachiopods.

Lab Work (Post-Field Trip)

Once students returned from their trip, we were ready to get to work! We started by cleaning the samples collected and organizing them by their visual characteristics. Then, they were ready to start their identification process! Students started to recognize fossils they had learned about in class: corals, bryozoans, and brachiopods. The specimens must be correctly identified to the family level for a final class project.

Comment from a student on their experience

“I was climbing around and hunting for fossils until I stumbled upon a good-looking area in the outcrop. I started digging around, and I found some organic matter that looked like an animal dropping. I was a little sketched out, so I started lifting rocks and digging around with my foot. As I began to look deeper, I found some more droppings, but I kept on digging anyway, until some creature came shooting out of a hole directly at me, I screamed and jumped back. It turned out this creature was a MASSIVEmole whose home I had interrupted! I didn’t think any animals would live in this area as it was super dry and rocky, but I guess that goes to show life will find a place even if you don’t think it can.” –Owen Walton ’27

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , | 1 Comment

Muscle scars in tiny conical fossils: A new paper describing the musculature of Devonian tentaculitids from Armenia and what they mean for the biology and evolution of the group

A new paper on tentaculitid paleobiology and evolution has just appeared in its final form in the journal Historical Biology. The authors are headed by my Estonian friend Olev Vinn and include two new Armenian colleagues Tamara Hambardzumyan and Vahram Serobyan, as well as American me. I did not get the opportunity to visit Armenia, alas. The image above shows four internal molds (steinkerns) of the studied Devonian tentaculitids from Armenia. The “msc” refers to muscle scars. (Figure 5 of the new paper.)

Tentaculitids are curious straight conical calcitic fossils with distinctive concentric ribbed ornamentation. They are found in rocks from the Ordovician through the Devonian. Sometimes they are incredibly abundant. For all their Paleozoic ubiquity, their systematic placement has been controversial. The microstructure of their calcite shells is very similar to that of the lophophorate brachiopods and bryozoans. For this reason and other evidence presented here and elsewhere it appears the tentaculitids are most closely related to bryozoans (Taylor et al., 2010; Vinn and Zatoń, 2012; Vinn et al., 2025a, 2025b). Above are tentaculitid original shells from the Devonian of Maryland (not used in this study).

Above are tentaculitid original shells from the Devonian of West Virginia (not used in this study).

Abstract

Rare soft body impressions were discovered on phosphatised steinkerns of Devonian tentaculitids from Armenia. The muscle scars occur only in the most apical part of the tentaculitid steinkerns. The morphology of muscle scars varies between different species. There are seven different types of muscle scars in tentaculitids, and six of them are present in the Armenian material. The muscle scars were used for attachment of a well-developed retractor muscle. The muscle attachments in tentaculitids migrated forwards during the growth of the shell like the muscle scars in many brachiopods. The hypothesised architecture of tentaculitid muscle system is most similar to that of bryozoans. Tentaculitids had a defensive mechanism that allowed complete retractability of the animal into the shell. This was achieved by prominent retractor muscles that pulled the soft tissues into the protective body wall. This is opposite the protrusion mechanism that involved body‐wall musculature to increase hydrostatic pressure within the soft body to squeeze out the feeding apparatus of the animal, enabling it to filter‐feed again. This muscle arrangement is strong evidence to confidently place the tentaculitids within the Lophotrochozoa, potentially as ‘lophophorates’.

Reconstruction of tentaculitid musculature (Figure 7 of the new paper). This is very similar to a bryozoan zooid.

References:

Taylor, P.D., Vinn, O. and Wilson, M.A. 2010. Evolution of biomineralization in ‘lophophorates’. Special Papers in Palaeontology 84: 317-333.

Vinn, O., Hambardzumyan, T., Wilson, M.A. and Serobyan, V. 2025a. Palaeobiological and phylogenetic implications of preserved muscle scars in Devonian tentaculitids from Armenia. Historical Biology 37:12, 2612-2620. https://doi.org/10.1080/08912963.2025.2458115

Vinn, O., Hambardzumyan, T., Temereva, E., Grigoryan, A., Tsatryan, M., Harutyunyan, L., Asatryan, K. and Serobyan, V. 2005b. Fossilized soft tissues in tentaculitids from the Upper Devonian of Armenia: Towards solving the mystery of their phylogenetic affinities. Palaeoworld 34, 3: 100888.

Vinn, O. and Zatoń, M. 2012. Phenetic phylogenetics of tentaculitoids – Extinct, problematic calcareous tube-forming organisms. GFF, 134(2), 145–156. https://doi.org/10.1080/11035897.2012.669788

 

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , | Leave a comment