Wooster’s Fossil of the Week: A cystoid (Middle Ordovician of northeastern Estonia)

Fossils don’t get much more spherical than Echinosphaerites aurantium, an extinct creature common in the Early and Middle Ordovician of North America and Europe. These are cystoids, a somewhat informal category of filter-feeding, stalked echinoderms that are relatives of the better known crinoids. My students and I found bucketloads of them in the oil shales of the Baltic country Estonia three years ago. They are like stony golf balls.

A typical cystoid has a sac-like theca forming the bulk of the body. This theca is made of dozens to hundreds of plates of the mineral calcite fitted together like tiles. On one end of the theca is a small stem to attach it to the substrate; the other end has short brachioles, which are filter-feeding arms surrounding a tiny mouth at their base. An anus is present on the side, distinguished by a circlet of special plates.

If you look carefully at the specimen on the left in the above illustration, you’ll see at least two sclerobionts (hard-substrate dwellers) attached to the theca.  The black branching form is a graptolite (like our last Fossil of the Week) called Thallograptus sphaericola (the species name means “sphere dweller”) and the raised disk is a bryozoan.

Every once in awhile the cystoids in Estonia were buried quickly and did not fill with sediment. The hollow space within became a kind of geode with crystals of calcite growing from the thecal plates inward. Each plate is a single crystal of calcite, so the crystals grew syntaxially (maintaining crystallographic continuity). These specimens are spectacular if broken open carefully so they don’t shatter into a thousand sparkles.

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , | 2 Comments

Wooster’s Fossil of the Week: A three-branched graptolite (Lower Ordovician of southeastern Australia)


This week I’m correcting a mistake I’ve been making in my paleontology courses for nearly thirty years. Our subject is a graptolite from the teaching collections — a specimen that has been at least cursorily examined by all of my paleontology students. It is not a particularly pretty fossil, but an important one for biostratigraphy and evolution.

Graptolites were colonial marine organisms which thrived from the Late Cambrian (roughly 510 million years ago) into the Early Carboniferous (about 350 million years ago). Their colonies, termed rhabdosomes, were not mineralized, so they are most commonly preserved as thin carbon films like our featured specimen. The rhabdosome usually began with a single individual, known as a sicula, that budded branches called stipes. Each stipe is lined with cup-like thecae that held what we presume were filter-feeding individuals termed zooids (much like bryozoans). The number of stipes per rhabdosome varies considerably, from one to dozens. Some graptolites were sessile benthic epifaunal (attached to the seafloor on hard surfaces) while others were planktic (suspended or floating).

Our specimen above is the planktic graptolite Pendeograptus fruticosus from the Lower Ordovician (about 477-474 million years old) near Bendigo, Australia. There are actually two specimens overlapping here. I’ve labeled one sicula as “S1” and the other as “S2”.

This is where my mistake began. I identified these graptolites during my first professorial year as Tetragraptus fruticosus, believing that there were two specimens with, as you might guess from the name, four stipes each. When I counted the actual stipes present, though, I found only three each. I believed, though, that graptolites had either one, two, four or many stipes, so specimens with only three had to have one stipe missing or folded over as to be invisible. So for the curious student who counted three where there should have been four, I confidently explained the preservational oddity. That both specimens lacked the fourth stipe did not apparently shake my resolve.

It was only after photographing this specimen that I looked closely enough to see that, indeed, three stipes are present and there is no evidence of a fourth for either rhabdosome. (I added numbers and letters to the above image to delineate the stipes.) Maybe there really are three-stiped graptolites? This was easily enough confirmed by simply Googling “three-stiped graptolite”. Who knew? This version of “Tetragraptus” is actually the genus Pendeograptus. Oops.

Turns out that our Pendeograptus fruticosus is part of an evolutionary series proceeding from four to three to two stipes. The three-stiped version we have is an indicator for the Australian Bendigonian Stage and a global index fossil for this narrow time interval 477 to 474 million years ago.

You can now see this specimen (without the red labels) on the Wikipedia page for graptolites. I’m correcting my mistake and sharing a useful little fossil with the world.

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , | Leave a comment

Wooster’s Fossil of the Week: The tabulate coral Aulopora (Devonian of northwestern Ohio)

We’re going to start 2011 with a new blog feature: Fossil of the Week! My colleagues, of course, are welcome to also start “Mineral of the Week”, “Structural Geologic Feature of the Week”, or “Climate Event of the Week”.  The more the better to keep our blog active through the winter!


This week’s fossil was collected by Brian Bade of Sullivan, Ohio, and donated to Wooster as part of my hederelloid project.  It is a beautiful specimen of the tabulate coral Aulopora encrusting a brachiopod valve from the Silica Shale (Middle Devonian — about 390 million years old) of northwestern Ohio.  Auloporid corals are characterized by an encrusting habit, a bifurcating growth pattern, and horn-shaped corallites (individual skeletal containers for the polyps).

What is especially nice about this specimen is that we are looking at a well preserved colony origin.  The corallite marked with the yellow “P” is the protocorallite — the first corallite from which all the others are derived.  You can see that two corallites bud out from the protocorallite 180° from each other.  These two corallites in turn each bud two corallites, but at about 160°.  This pattern continues as the colony develops (a process called astogeny).  The angles of budding begin to vary depending on local obstacles; they never again go below 160°.

The polyps inside the corallites are presumed to have been like other colonial coral polyps.  Each would have had tentacles surrounding a central opening, and all were connecting by soft tissue within the skeleton.  They likely fed on zooplankton in the surrounding seawater.  This type of coral went extinct in the Permian, roughly 260 million years ago.

Again, we thank our amateur geologist friends for such useful donations to the research and educational collections in the Geology Department at Wooster.

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , | 3 Comments

Wooster Geologists Pass Through Travel Hell

I think the lowest moment was this morning as I stood in one of those long, snaking security lines in the Delta portion of Terminal 3 at JFK International Airport. The high ceiling has pigeon nests in it, and the evil birds occasionally fly over the helpless travelers below and poop on their heads.

Following on our previous “Heathrow Diversion” post, this is our final report on a failed geological trip. Because of the snow and ice in England, our London flight was alternately canceled and reinstated (or at least that’s how it was communicated to us). We feared yet another mid-Atlantic diversion or, worse, getting to Heathrow and not being able to return home before the holidays. After many little adventures, we gave up on getting to London. I just arrived in Wooster and Megan is on a flight home to Detroit. My luggage, of course, is missing in action, but fortunately I did not keep in it the Permian type specimens or our Cretaceous collection. [Update: My luggage apparently never left Detroit!]

Throughout this journey we were accompanied by people who just want to get home to their families for the holidays. Here’s to their safe and successful travels.

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , | 2 Comments

“The Heathrow Diversion”: Wooster Geologists unexpectedly in New York City

A street scene outside our hotel in New York.

FLUSHING, QUEENS, NEW YORK–It seemed like such a good plan months ago. My Senior Independent Study student Megan Innis and I worked this summer in the American South with Paul Taylor and Caroline Sogot, as documented in this blog. We collected hundreds of fossils from the Late Cretaceous and Early Paleogene, many of which are encrusted with nearly perfectly-preserved bryozoans, serpulids and foraminiferans. The best way to study them is with a Scanning Electron Microscope (SEM), and the world’s expert in such paleontological imaging AND bryozoans is Paul Taylor himself. Since Paul is at The Natural History Museum in London, we planned to take our best specimens to him after classes were over in the Fall and before Christmas. That was the plan — and it still may work out!

Somewhere over Halifax our flight was diverted from London Heathrow because an epic snow and ice storm closed the runways. Delta flew us into JFK International Airport and put us up in a hotel in the middle of Flushing, Queens, New York City. Our flight will be reconstituted this evening and we’ll try again to reach London (and get out on Thursday, we can only hope). We are persevering because this is an important part of Megan’s I.S. project (for which she received Copeland Funds from the college), the fossils we bring will be significant for Caroline and Paul (and they have some for us), and I’m also hand-delivering a set of type specimens from the Permian of Texas. So in the interest of science and education we will soldier through!

In the meantime we are staying in a fascinating neighborhood. It certainly is one of the most diverse places on Earth as it has a colonial understructure (going back to the 17th Century Dutch) and added layers of culture through the centuries. We would have never guessed we’d be wandering its streets today!

Megan examining dried mushrooms and other unknown items outside a Korean-American grocery store in New York.

We even found a bit of geology to discuss in a World War I memorial. Geology is everywhere.

A 1920s marble memorial to World War I soldiers in Flushing, Queens, New York City.

This marble is odd because it has layers rich in muscovite mica. When Megan pointed these out I didn't believe her, but she was right.

There are also inclusions in the marble that look like hornblende. Our petrologist Dr. Pollock will have to figure this one out for us!

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , | 2 Comments

The paleontology of hiatus concretions: fossils without sediment

Bryozoans (the thin branching structures) and an edrioasteroid (with the "star") encrusting a hiatus concretion from the Kope Formation (Upper Ordovician) of northern Kentucky.

Way back in 1984, when I was just a green Assistant Professor of Geology, my wife Gloria and I explored a series of Upper Ordovician (about 445 million years old) outcrops in northern Kentucky to plan a paleontology course field trip. It was a rainy day were, as is too often the case, slippery with mud. On our last roadcut exposure of the day I stepped out of the car and found at my feet the cobble pictured above. It had edrioasteroid echinoderms and bryozoans encrusting it on all sides — and we knew we had found something special. We collected dozens of the cobbles in a few minutes. It changed my research trajectory by introducing me to the splendors of hard substrate communities and hiatus concretions.

This post is a celebration of another chapter of that work published next month in the journal Facies (volume 57, pp. 275-300). This time I’m a member of a large team led by my young friend and colleague Michal Zaton of the University of Silesia in Sosnowiec. We thoroughly examined a set of bored and encrusted cobbles from the Middle Jurassic (about 170 million years old) of south-central Poland. It was a pleasure to use some of the same research techniques I employed 26 years ago to help reconstruct an ancient ecosystem and environment.

Hiatus concretions from the Middle Jurassic of Poland.

These cobbles are known as “hiatus concretions” because they collect in an environment when sediment has stopped (gone on “hiatus”, I suppose) and a lag of hard debris accumulates when fine sediment is washed away by currents. Organisms which require a hard substrate (“sclerobionts”) encrust the cobble surfaces (bryozoans, echinoderms, oysters and serpulid worms are most common) or bore into the matrix (sponges, bivalves, barnacles and worms commonly do this). A fossil record thus is formed in the absence of sedimentation, which is a bit different from the usual paradigm.

Various encrusters and borings on hiatus concretions from the Middle Jurassic of Poland.

Encrusting bryozoans on hiatus concretions from the Middle Jurassic of Poland.

I enjoy studying marine hard substrate organisms through time because they show a type of community evolution over hundreds of millions of years. These diverse fossils have also provided countless research opportunities for my Wooster students, and tracking them down has taken us all over the world and throughout the geological column. (The Cretaceous of Israel is another recent example of this work.) It is very satisfying to see a young geologist like Michal Zaton finding pleasure and research success in the same pursuit.

Bryozoans and crinoid holdfasts encrusting a cobble from the Upper Ordovician Kope Formation of northern Kentucky.

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , | 4 Comments

Memories of warmer days…

Now that the semester is winding down and the cold weather has set in, I find my mind wandering back to the beginning of the academic year. It seems like it was years ago, not months, that our Mineralogy class visited Zollinger’s quarry.

2010 Mineralogy class at Zollinger's Quarry in late September.

It didn’t take long for students to discover the beautifully formed gypsum crystals that littered the ground.

From left to right, Will Cary, Matt Peppers, and Kevin Silver caught in the act of discovering the gypsum.

Truly, these are beautiful gypsum crystals.

In fact, next week  we’re using some of the crystals that we collected in our discussion of the thermodynamics of crystal nucleation and growth.

Of course, the minerals weren’t the only stars of the show. The students were excited to find these incredible mud cracks with preserved rain drops –  comparable to these mud cracks that a fellow geologist at Mountain Beltway observed in Turkey.

Mud cracks and preserved rain drops in Zollinger's Quarry.

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , | Leave a comment

A very volcanic tour of New Zealand’s North Island

Mount Ngauruhoe on the North Island of New Zealand.

Our most distant Wooster Geologist this year, Andrew Collins, is now home from his semester abroad in New Zealand. He had many geological adventures, including that massive earthquake in Christchurch with its hundreds of aftershocks. Please visit his blog for the stories.

Andrew’s last trip in New Zealand was to Tongariro National Park (a UNESCO World Heritage site) on the North Island. He had, as he wrote, “a spectacular trek” of 20 kilometers between two volcanoes: Mt Tongariro and Mt Ngauruhoe, with a third volcano, Mt Ruapehu, always in view. Mt Ngauruhoe was, as you might have guessed, used as “Mount Doom” in a certain movie series the New Zealanders make a fuss about.

Please enjoy Andrew’s beautiful photographs in this post, and then go to his blog to see them and many others in full size. We are very proud of this Wooster Geology odyssey, and we are also happy to have Andrew safely home!

You can just barely see Andrew as he climbs to the summit of Mt Tongariro.

Note the bright red layers of volcanic cinders.

Beautiful, mineral-filled emerald lakes.

Mineralization along a stream flowing through this active volcanic region.

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , | 5 Comments

Trays of trilobites, buckets of belemnites ….

WOOSTER, OHIO — Last weekend we picked up another load of rocks, minerals and fossils donated by the family of one of our loyal alumni. We will be sorting through them for months getting them ready for displays and our teaching collections. Among the treasures are large numbers of particular items, especially fossils. I want to highlight two of many such sets. The trilobites are Phacops bufo from the Silica Shale (Devonian) of northeastern Ohio; the belemnites below are from the Jurassic of Wyoming. (Belemnites from the Upper Cretaceous of Germany and the Jurassic of Israel have been featured in this blog, as have beautiful trilobites from the Middle Cambrian of British Columbia, Canada.) Numerous nearly-identical fossils such as these play an important role in our teaching. We can, for example, have a fossil in front of each student during lectures for immediate reference (and quizzing!). It is also possible to have biometric measuring exercises in our labs with these fossil “populations” of particular species. Gifts again put to work in education!

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , | Leave a comment

An Afternoon of Rocks and Minerals at Cornerstone Elementary

Tuesday we had the pleasure to work with Mrs. Gaut’s and Ms Long’s (standing) third grade classes. Wooster Geology seniors Stephanie Jarvis and LaShawna Weeks taught 32 well-prepared students mineral and rock identification.

LaShawna shows the group the fine art of using the streak plate in mineral identification.

Steph explains the characteristics of metamorphism. The fellow in the lower left is eager to share his view of the processes associated with metamorphic rocks.

LaShawna discusses the formation of sandstone and quizzes the group on the depositional environment.

Steph explains the nuances of the rates of mineral crystallization.

It was clear that the group was ready to take their new knowledge of 14 minerals and 10 rocks to the next level.

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged | 1 Comment