Paleoenvironmental analysis of the Silurian Jaani Formation on the island of Saaremaa, Estonia (Senior Independent Study Thesis by Rob McConnell)

Editor’s note: Senior Independent Study (I.S.) is a year-long program at The College of Wooster in which each student completes a research project and thesis with a faculty mentor.  We particularly enjoy I.S. in the Geology Department because there are so many cool things to do for both the faculty advisor and the student.  We are now posting abstracts of each study as they become available.  The following was written by Rob McConnell, a senior geology major from Darby, Montana.  Here is a link to his final PowerPoint presentation on this project.

In the summer of 2009, Wooster paleontologists Dr. Mark Wilson, Palmer Shonk, and I traveled to Estonia with fellow Ohio State University paleontologist Dr. Bill Ausich. Olev Vinn of the University of Tartu greeted us at the Tallinn Airport. We then proceeded by car to the island of Saaremaa in western Estonia. The city of Kuressaare would serve as our home for the next week as we conducted our research on the island.

My research describes two members of the Jaani Formation (Silurian, Wenlock): the older Mustjala Member and the younger Ninase Member. Samples of these two members were collected from three sites along the northern Saaremaa coast:  Liiva Cliff, Suuriku Cliff, and Panga Cliff (Figure 1).

Figure 1. Jaani Formation at Panga Cliff, Saaremaa, Estonia.

Figure 1. Jaani Formation at Panga Cliff, Saaremaa, Estonia.

The purpose of my research is to describe and recreate the paleoenvironment of the Jaani Formation. I am doing this by analyzing thin-section slides, stromatoporoid sponges (Figure 2), and various other fossils such as corals and brachiopods. It appears thus far that the lower Mustjala Member is far more fossiliferous and contains larger stromatoporoids, many of which are still in life position. This indicates a tranquil shallow marine environment. Smaller and flatter sponges are found in the upper Mustjala Member, close to the Mustjala/Ninase boundary. This is likely because of a shallowing of the water through time (a regression).

Figure 2. Stromatoporoids from the Mustjala Member, Jaani Formation (Silurian, Wenlock) on Saaremaa, Estonia.

Figure 2. Stromatoporoids from the Mustjala Member, Jaani Formation (Silurian, Wenlock) on Saaremaa, Estonia.

The Ninase Member has different characteristics than the Mustjala. In general, it is better cemented and contains fewer fossils. It also contains more brachiopods and fewer sponges. It may have been deposited in a higher energy environment. Continued analysis of both members is required to gain a better understanding of this approximately 420 million year old environment.

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , | 1 Comment

Paleoenvironmental Reconstruction of the Late Silurian (Pridoli) Äigu Beds of Saaremaa Island, Estonia (Senior Independent Study Thesis by Palmer Shonk)

Editor’s note: Senior Independent Study (I.S.) is a year-long program at The College of Wooster in which each student completes a research project and thesis with a faculty mentor.  We particularly enjoy I.S. in the Geology Department because there are so many cool things to do for both the faculty advisor and the student.  We are now posting abstracts of each study as they become available.  The following was written by Palmer Shonk, a senior geology major from Dublin, New Hampshire.  Here is a link to his final PowerPoint presentation on this project.

I traveled to Estonia in July of 2009 with my advisor, Dr. Mark Wilson, Dr. Bill Ausich of The Ohio State University, and fellow Wooster geology major Robert McConnell. Upon arrival, we were greeted by Dr. Olev Vinn, his wife Ingrid, and their baby daughter. Olev is a geology professor at Tartu University in Estonia. The seven of us then headed for the island of Saaremaa, where I carried out my research. We stayed in the town of Kuressaare, on the southern shore of the island. My field site, the Äigu Beds, is about a 20 minute drive southwest of Kuressaare, on the western shore of the Sõrve Peninsula.

The Äigu Beds (Figure 1) are part of the Kaugatuma formation, named after the nearby town of Kaugatuma. My goal is to use the fossils and lithology at the beds to reconstruct an environment 418 million years old. My group assisted me in collecting fossils from three distinct layers. The first layer, about 8 cm thick, is an argillaceous limestone and contains many fossils still in life position, particularly crinoid holdfasts (Figure 2). This layer represents a calm, shallow-marine environment with soft, submarine dunes. The second layer, about 17 cm thick, shows evidence of a high energy event such as a storm. Fossils in the second layer have been crushed and are cemented together. The third layer, about 30 cm thick, is comprised again of the argillaceous limestone of layer one, but also shows evidence of a small scale high-energy event due to its “mashed” fossil specimens.

Figure 1. Part of the Äigu Beds on Saaremaa Island, Estonia; Late Silurian in age; note green pen for scale.

Figure 1. Part of the Äigu Beds on Saaremaa Island, Estonia; Late Silurian in age; note green pen for scale.

Figure 2. Crinoid holdfast from the first layer at the Äigu Beds; note tip of pen for scale.

Figure 2. Crinoid holdfast from the first layer at the Äigu Beds; note tip of pen for scale.

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , | 5 Comments

Wooster Geologists Speak on the 2010 Haiti Earthquake

Picture 1

WOOSTER, OHIO–The Wooster Geology Department faculty spoke today to the campus about the geological framework of the cataclysmic January 2010 earthquake near Port-au-Prince, Haiti.  Greg Wiles started with an overview of plate tectonic theory and how the dynamic Earth makes earthquakes inevitable.  Meagen Pollock discussed the mechanics and measurements of earthquakes and why they can cause so much damage.  Shelley Judge explained the particular Caribbean fault system which produced the Haiti earthquake.  Mark Wilson then finished with a review of the historical major earthquakes along that fault zone.  You can view their Haiti Earthquake PowerPoint slide presentation here.

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , | 1 Comment

A Wooster Geologist on the 2012 Doomsday Phenomenon: Pseudoscience, Baseless Fears, and the Mysterious Planet Nibiru

Slide1

WOOSTER, OHIO–Last week I gave a talk about the coming End of Time scheduled for December 21, 2012.  You may have heard that the Mayan Long Count Calendar ends on the day before the 2012 winter solstice, and that all sorts of global catastrophes have been predicted to mark the event.  I was invited by Ohio State University Mansfield and North Central State College to describe the cataclysmic ideas about 2012 and explore the pseudoscience behind them.  It was a good opportunity to explore the value of science and scientific thinking … and hearty skepticism.

I’ve attached the 2012 lecture here as a PowerPoint file which should open in your browser with a click-through display.  There is no audio, alas, so you’ll just have to imagine the jokes.

You might also be interested in the “living syllabus” of our First-Year Seminar course on “Nonsense“.

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , | 11 Comments

Voices of Undergraduate Geoscience Research

Two Wooster geologists, Colin Mennett (’10) and Terry Workman (’10), are featured Voices of Undergraduate Geoscience Research on the Council for Undergraduate Research (CUR) Geoscience Division website. Colin and Terry were interviewed by a CUR Councilor when they presented their research at the 2009 Annual GSA Meeting in Portland, OR. In the podcasts, Colin and Terry discuss the benefits, difficulties, and strategies of working one-on-one with faculty on a year-long Independent Study. If you’ve ever wondered what it’s like to do an I.S. at Wooster, here’s your opportunity to hear about a couple of first-hand experiences! Enjoy!

Colin Mennett CUR Interview

Terry Workman CUR Interview

Coin Mennett explains the results of his work in using tree-rings to investigate the Alaskan Cedar Decline.

Colin Mennett explains the results of his work in using tree-rings to investigate the Alaskan Cedar Decline.

Terry Workman and Alena Giesche presented results of their work in Alaska. Their poster entitled DEVELOPING A PROXY RECORD FOR MOISTURE VARIABILITY THROUGH THE HOLOCENE FOR THE KENAI LOWLANDS, ALASKA, KENAI NATIONAL WILDLIFE REFUGE

Terry Workman and Alena Giesche presented results of their work in Alaska. Their poster entitled DEVELOPING A PROXY RECORD FOR MOISTURE VARIABILITY THROUGH THE HOLOCENE FOR THE KENAI LOWLANDS, ALASKA, KENAI NATIONAL WILDLIFE REFUGE

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , | 1 Comment

Hazards Blog

Check out the GEOL 105 Blog: http://geol105naturalhazards.voices.wooster.edu/
Get to know the students over the week as they discuss their favorite hazards. Then follow the blog for updated information on current hazard-related events!

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , | Leave a comment

Earthquakes and the Power of the Internet

It’s amazing how quickly information moves on the internet. I was working on my Natural Hazards course today when Twitter exploded with news of a magnitude 4.1 earthquake in northern California.

USGS shake map for Jan 7 4.1 magnitude Bay Area earthquake

USGS shake map for Jan 7 4.1 magnitude Bay Area earthquake

Within minutes, the USGS posted details on a website, complete with maps and list of people who reported that they felt it. Incredibly, in just less than an hour after the event, a total of 13,372 people reported this earthquake to the Did You Feel It? website. The number of people who felt it continues to grow.

Given all of the information sources on the web (blogs, organization web pages, Twitter, etc.), it will certainly be a challenge for my Natural Hazards students to keep up with and critically analyze information about current hazard-related events.

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , | 1 Comment

Lunar Ilmenite

Lunar Ilmenite: Next Gen Fuel Source Part 1 and Part 2 presented by Andrew Retzler ’11.

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , | 1 Comment

The joy of thin-sections

A beautiful view of a modern hardground in thin-section.  The platy orange, pinkish and brown grains are the mineral biotite (a mica), the gray and white angular grains are quartz, and the tan irregular grains are recrystallized shells and cements.  Sampled dredged from about 650 meters in the Strait of Messina between the Italian mainland and Sicily.  Collected by Agostina Vertino.

A beautiful view of a modern hardground in thin-section with cross-polarized light. The platy pinkish and brown grains are the minerals muscovite and biotite (micas), the gray and white angular grains are quartz, and the tan irregular grains are recrystallized shells and cements. Sample dredged from about 650 meters in the Strait of Messina between the Italian mainland and Sicily. Collected by Agostina Vertino.

WOOSTER, OHIO–Bitterly cold Ohio days are perfect for geological lab work, especially with thin-sections under a warm microscope accompanied by a music-filled iPod. The next best thing to fieldwork. A thin-section is a slice of polished rock glued to a microscope slide and then ground down to a standard thickness of 30 microns so that light easily passes through it. Minerals, fossils and other internal features become visible in a thin-section which would otherwise go unnoticed in the hand sample. We use polarized light to reveal optical properties of the crystals for identification and analysis. Often a thin-section in cross-polarized light shows an astonishing array of colors, fabrics and textures.

What is most fun is to take a drab rock and find the microscopic treasures within through thin-sectioning. For example, this is the rock I worked with today:

A hardground sample from the Strait of Messina (the same rock as seen in the thin-section above).  This sample was dredged from the deep-sea and is encrusted by the coral Desmophyllum dianthus and tiny tubeworms.  Collected by Agostina Vertino.

A hardground (cemented seafloor) sample from the Strait of Messina (the same rock as seen in the thin-section above). This sample was dredged from the deep-sea and is encrusted by the coral Desmophyllum dianthus and tiny tubeworms. Collected by Agostina Vertino.

A sample of the same hardground as above with the organic material removed.  On the right is a closer view of the sand-sized grains making up the rock.  Notice that even in this view you can tell that the grains are poorly cemented to each other -- the rock is very crumbly.

A sample of the same hardground as above with the organic material removed. On the right is a closer view of the sand-sized grains making up the rock. Notice that even in this view you can tell that the grains are poorly cemented to each other.

An Italian colleague (Agostina Vertino of the Dipartimento Scienze Geologiche – Università Catania) and I are examining these unusual hardgrounds from deep in the underwater canyon at the bottom of the Strait of Messina. This is a very energetic system (the currents are fast), so the grain size is surprisingly coarse for a deep-water deposit. The composition of the sediment is highly variable, ranging from feldspars and micas to shell fragments and microscopic skeletons of foraminiferans. Our first question is the simplest: How are these sediments cemented? The thin-sections show us.

Carbonate rock fragments in the Strait of Messina hardground showing a thin fringe of calcareous cement (probably aragonite) precipitated on their edges.  The cement is formed when these crystalline fringes intersect and hold the grains together.

Carbonate rock fragments in the Strait of Messina hardground showing a thin fringe of calcareous crystals (probably aragonite) precipitated on their edges. The cement is formed when these crystalline fringes intersect and hold the grains together.

As you would expect, a rock so lightly cemented crumbles easily, and it has a very high porosity and permeability. It is remarkable that such an unstable substrate serves so well as an attachment surface for encrusting organisms such as corals, tubeworms, bryozoans and sponges.

The dark areas in this thin-section view (as in the others) are open spaces.  This particular hardground is highly porous and permeable.

The black areas in this thin-section view (as in the others) are open spaces. This particular hardground is highly porous and permeable. Note the bright fringing cements on the grains.

The porosity and permeability of this sediment is undoubtedly a key to its cementation. Fluids could move quickly and in considerable volume through this deposit, gradually precipitating the tiny, tiny calcareous crystals on the exposed grain surfaces. It is also possible that dissolving aragonite shells in the sediment supplied the necessary carbonate for the cement. There is much work ahead to figure that one out.

We will post more portraits of our geological laboratory studies this winter as we simultaneously prepare for next summer’s fieldwork. This is the life!

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , | Leave a comment

Wooster Geologist in Ohio!

CAESAR CREEK STATE PARK, OHIO–I’ve definitely extended my field season as far as possible.  (And what a season it has been.)  My last fieldwork at the end of this research leave was in Ohio, about three hours south of Wooster.  I visited Caesar Creek State Park this morning where a large cut through an Upper Ordovician section has been set aside as a fossil preserve of sorts.  It is an emergency spillway for Caesar Creek Lake, which is maintained by the US Army Corps of Engineers.  Many Wooster paleontology field trips have stopped here.  Fossils can be collected, but only with a permit (obtained at the visitor center) and following significant regulations.  The fossils are diverse and abundant, including all the stars of the Ordovician seafloor.

My task was to find, photograph and measure an old trace fossil friend: the boring Petroxestes pera.  This is a slot-shaped excavation in carbonate hard substrates formed by bivalves (probably in this case the modiomorphid Corallidomus).

The boring Petroxestes pera (the name means "purse-shaped rock-grinding") in a hardground at Caesar Creek State Park.

The boring Petroxestes pera (the name means "purse-shaped rock-grinding") in a hardground at Caesar Creek State Park.

These elongated holes are among the first bivalve borings.  Some of my students and I think they may have been formed in clusters, and they also may be oriented relative to each other and their local environment.  In any case, I found plenty.  It was an astonishingly cold morning, though, so I didn’t waste any time on the outcrop!

Yes, this photo is here mainly to show just how tough Wooster Geologists are.  And there are some very nice brachiopods and bryozoans!

Yes, this photo is here mainly to show just how tough Wooster Geologists are. And there are some very nice brachiopods and bryozoans!

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , , | 1 Comment